I've just slogged through J K Rowling's incredibly long essay (see here) on why she's not a transphobe. We could analyse all the arguments for and against young people transitions and the statistics on the number of people who detransition but I have to say of it all this is the bit I found most revealing...
"As I didn’t have a realistic possibility of becoming a man back in the
1980s, it had to be books and music that got me through both my mental
health issues and the sexualised scrutiny and judgement that sets so
many girls to war against their bodies in their teens. Fortunately for
me, I found my own sense of otherness, and my ambivalence about being a
woman, reflected in the work of female writers and musicians who
reassured me that, in spite of everything a sexist world tries to throw
at the female-bodied, it’s fine not to feel pink, frilly and compliant
inside your own head; it’s OK to feel confused, dark, both sexual and
non-sexual, unsure of what or who you are."
That's a bit close to saying you were actually trans but didn't transition because the technology was not available at the time. That's to say ...is it me or is J K coming out of the trans closet? If there is such a place and that's not homophobic ...
Now this may be cherry picking by me or an ad hominem attack but I just don't understand why people get so fixated by this issue. I wandered over to Graham Linehan's Facebook page the other day to find out what goes on and there was a Girl Guide leader complaining about transitioning boys joining the Girl Guides who unlike the Scouts have not decided to let both sexes in but do allow trans girls. You listen to this stuff for a while and maybe I'm an old mysinogist but in the end you just think "get a life" or "it's not a hill of beans". I've never really understood why single sex organisations need to exist. This is probably because I resented going to a single sex school. Mind you I don't think they shouldn't exist but if one man gets into a group of 20 women how is that the end of the world? I see why people who are minorities or oppressed would want to form groups that are mutually supportive and I think there's probably little or no harm in such gatherings...
...but if you stop shopping in Marks and Spensors or Primark because there are unisex changing rooms you're a bit silly given that there are rows of completely private cubicals ... I can understand that there might be more problems in communal swimming bath changing rooms but...
I'll shut up forever now before I start a twitter war.
Multi
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Sir Alec Burnham Douglas-Home ...
The Labour Party plans to dump Starmer after the disastrous local election results but they don't want him to go but "set a timetab...
Least ignored nonsense this month...
-
The Labour Party plans to dump Starmer after the disastrous local election results but they don't want him to go but "set a timetab...
-
Discovering that Morgan McSweeny & Mr Mandelson had a spreadsheet of every potential Labour Councillor and their peccadilloes I was rem...
-
I was discussing the other day online the worst sequels ever made which is a tough call but I think Superman IV just pips the post. The e...
-
.... since the Council is perpetually bankrupt and in special measures and run by Commissioners there is literally no point in voting becau...
-
Blondi (Hitler's dog) is on the right. Braun's dogs and Blondi's puppies were shot on by Hitler's dog handler Fritz Tornow. ...
-
Anthony, we’ve never seen anything like this. In the days since Caroline Flack’s tragic death, more than three quarters of a million peopl...
-
CORRECT ME IF I'M WRONG BUT, As I turn 52 this year, I have realised, as a man, no one cares about you. Not your wife. Not your family. ...
-
Birds do it Bees do it Even Ayatollah Khomeinis do it Let's do it Let's bomb Iran Boats in the Straights Of Hormuz do it Arabs in ot...
-
The Royal Family today visited the Royal Vault at Saint George's Chapel Windsor to celebrate the hundredth birthday of Queen Elizabeth I...
-
My favourite bleat of Trump supporters trying to explain the oncoming economic catastrophe or his dalliances with far right dictators or thr...
No comments:
Post a Comment